Classic cocktail · Guided recipe

Tommy’s Margarita

Start making

The margarita stripped back: good tequila, fresh lime and agave instead of orange liqueur. Cleaner, brighter, all about the tequila.

Preparation~2 minEasyStrengthStrongabout 23% ABVMethodShaken8 guided stepsIngredients3Short (rocks) glass
Sour

In the glassTequila (blanco) · Fresh lime juice · Agave syrup

See exact amounts
Tommy’s Margarita in a heavy low rocks glass styled in a quiet coastal Mexican bar with faded coral plaster, dark stone and a slatted palm shadow.
Make it with guidanceOne clear action at a time, with timers built in.

What goes in

Ingredients

An empty clear rocks glass with low straight sides and a heavy base.
Serving glassRocks glass

Set up before you pour

Use a rocks glass.

The low, sturdy bowl suits concentrated drinks and gives one large cube enough width.

Standard size
300 ml10¼ oz
Ice & serve
Fill it with fresh ice cubes.
If you don’t own one
Use a small water tumbler with a heavy base.
Tools to set out
  • cocktail shaker
  • strainer (or a small sieve)
  • jigger or measuring spoon
Compare all glass types
Scale to your short (rocks) glassWe’ll remember this glass size.
  • Tequila (blanco)60 ml
  • Fresh lime juice30 ml
  • Agave syrup15 ml

From bottle to glass

Method

  1. 01
    Instructional sketch: Measure and pour spirit vodka into the shaker tin without serving ice.
    Measure into the shaker

    Pour 60 ml tequila into your shaker

    • Tequila (blanco)
  2. 02
    Instructional sketch: Measure and pour fresh lime into the shaker tin without serving ice.
    Measure into the shaker

    Add 30 ml fresh lime juice

    • Fresh lime juice
  3. 03
    Instructional sketch: Measure and pour pantry syrup into the shaker tin without serving ice.
    Measure into the shaker

    Add 15 ml agave syrup

    • Agave syrup
  4. 04
    Instructional sketch: Add cubed ice to the shaker tin.
    Ice the shaker

    Fill the shaker with ice

  5. 05
    Instructional sketch: Seal the two-piece shaker and shake it firmly with both hands.
    Seal and shake

    Seal and shake hard

  6. 06
    Instructional sketch: Add cubed ice to the rocks glass.
    Ice the glass

    Fill your glass with fresh ice

  7. 07
    Instructional sketch: Strain the gold cocktail from the shaker into the rocks glass with cubed ice.
    Strain cleanly

    Strain into your glass

  8. 08
    Instructional sketch: Finish the gold drink in the rocks glass with cubed ice with Lime Wheel.
    Finish the drink

    Finish it — add a lime wheel

Know your drink

About the Tommy’s Margarita

A salt-rimmed Margarita, coral Paloma and mezcal rocks drink on an agave terrace.

Where the agave came in

Julio Bermejo is credited with the recipe at his family's restaurant in San Francisco, where he swapped orange liqueur for agave syrup to show off the 100 percent agave tequilas he was championing. The change caught on because it does something useful: it makes the drink a test of the tequila rather than a way to disguise it.

Two parts tequila, one part lime, half a part agave. Worth memorizing, because it scales cleanly to a pitcher and it's the frame for most agave sours you'll meet. If a batch tastes thin the next day, that's dilution from shaking done too early, not the recipe.

Common questions

Tommy’s Margarita FAQ

Do I need to thin the agave syrup first?

Yes. Straight from the bottle, agave nectar is thick enough to sink to the bottom of the shaker and sweeter than simple syrup by roughly half again. Stir two parts nectar with one part warm water, keep it in the fridge, and use the fifteen milliliters as written.

Should the glass have a salt rim?

Traditionally no. Salt does its best work covering for a rough mixto tequila and the sugar of orange liqueur, and neither is in this glass. If you want it anyway, salt half the rim so you can choose sip by sip, and use flaky salt rather than table salt.

Which tequila should I buy for this?

Blanco, and check that the label says one hundred percent agave. Anything labeled gold or mixto is up to half cane sugar and tastes like it in a drink this bare. Reposado works if you like a rounder, vanilla-tinged version, though it softens the lime edge.

What does dropping the orange liqueur actually change?

Sweetness moves from a 30 percent liqueur to a non-alcoholic syrup, so the drink gets slightly weaker and considerably drier, and the orange perfume disappears. What's left is agave against lime. Good tequila gains from that, and anything harsh has nowhere to hide.

What ingredients are in a Tommy’s Margarita?

A classic Tommy’s Margarita calls for 60 ml (2 oz) Tequila, 30 ml (1 oz) Fresh lime juice, 15 ml (0.5 oz) Agave syrup. That single-serve spec scales cleanly — the recipe above converts it to oz and multiplies it for 2–4 drinks.

How strong is a Tommy’s Margarita?

A standard Tommy’s Margarita is roughly 23% ABV once mixed (before ice melt softens it further). That makes it spirit-forward — closer to a Martini than to a beer, so sip it slowly.

Is a Tommy’s Margarita shaken or stirred?

A Tommy’s Margarita is shaken — the rule of thumb is to shake anything with citrus juice. About 13 seconds with plenty of ice chills and dilutes it correctly.